Showing posts with label James A. Tyrrell. Show all posts
Showing posts with label James A. Tyrrell. Show all posts

Saturday, April 25, 2009

Malta IS a concrete jungle...let's Gozo NOW!

Monday, 26th January 2009


Gozo airstrip still seems pie in the sky

Those who for years have been making proposals to have a reliable air link to Gozo fear nothing concrete will ever be done, even though the government said recently it was open to "economically feasible" suggestions.

The island has been without a land-based air connection since the helicopter service was stopped in 2005. It is only served by a seaplane from Grand Harbour, a service which does not run in winter.

Some people have been pushing for the infrastructure at the inactive Gozo helipad, in Xewkija, to be put back to use by building a runway as an extension.

"No one is taking it seriously," Roy Perry, who submitted the proposal in 1997, said in a disappointed voice. He added that he did not know of anyone who objected to the project, as long as it did not have adverse environmental consequences, something he said his plans guarantee.

He is just one of the enthusiasts who have come up with creative solutions to the problem of having no direct air link between Luqa airport and Gozo in the absence of the old helicopter connection.

When the service was cancelled, a seaplane operation was set up from the Grand Harbour. But this cannot function when it is dark or the sea is rough and, consequently, stops flying during the winter months. Also, since it is based at the Grand Harbour, it does not enable quick transfers from the airport to Gozo.

Mr Perry argued that in the light of the difficult year ahead for tourism, this was one project that should be concluded as soon as possible in order to create an efficient, reliable and cost-effective service. He estimates the flight would cost about €75 return and it would take 15 minutes to get from Malta to Gozo.

The secretary of the Gozo Tourism Association, Joe Muscat, has in the past argued that the seaplane is no substitute for a proper air link between the airport and Gozo. A runway was needed to attract tourism, he insisted. The operation of a fixed-wing aircraft would require a small airstrip but, in view of environmental concerns, the association has proposed that the secondary road behind the heliport, linking Għajnsielem to Xewkija, could be developed for this purpose.

The road would only be closed to traffic while aircraft were operating.

Pilot and aviation investor Victor Mercieca has come up with yet another proposal: for the runway to be built on reclaimed land at the Mġarr Harbour. However, this would be more costly and time-consuming because it would involve the building of an artificial extension to the breakwater.

The different proposals have been discussed by the authorities a number of times and, although no final decisions have been taken, all parties involved seem to agree that an air link is desirable.

The Gozo Business Chamber is all in favour of the airstrip but its president, Joe Grech, said he had received no updates about the proposals submitted.

When contacted, the Gozo Ministry said it too wanted a decision to be taken and that it was in favour of a "sustainable and reliable air service" but did not comment about the proposals available.

Comments

M.Bezzina (on 27/1/09)
@H Dempster

Malta is a concrete jungle!!Hope you did not choose or you dont choose Malta to live when you retire!!
Victor G.Mercieca (on 26/1/09)
@ Mr.Dempster,Mr.Shields,& Mr.Green,
It appears from your comments that you are all expats retired in Gozo? & have no need to commute almost daily to work like most people do from both sides & who have to wake up in the early hours to meet the current slow surface schedule! Most level headed people realize that you are the usual armchairs critics who basically enjoy installing negative perceptions against a vital GA Airstrip(Incidently 50% of the infrastructure is in place) much needed for sustainable & consistant commerce,tourism paralleling with Malta & will also put Gozo as a direct niche GA destination from now Schengen Europe....It is true that GA in Malta is flourishing, thanks to many local dediciated professional indivisuals, aero clubs, pilots associations, flight schools with their great personal efforts & expense will certainly operate in & out of Gozo, at the great benefit of the general public as an alternative choice to commute in less time consuming, in a safe & cost effective manner!
John Azzopardi (on 26/1/09)
Gozo needs a some form of air service. period. Gozo is a forward looking island, and by denying an air service to it's inhabitant and tax paying citizens is not right. When we had the helipter service, tourist loved it. I know that there are several foreigners living in Gozo are against an air service. But, times change and the time has come for Gozo to have back some form of an air service. It's a need that cannot be denied.
James A. Tyrrell (on 26/1/09)
The same old argument which raises it’s ugly head every few months. Gozo does not need an airstrip. Roy Perry says that he knows of no one who is against it. Is he living under a stone somewhere? No one wants it period!

Also I wish people would stop using tourists like myself as an excuse for building an airstrip. Tourists like myself enjoy the peace and quiet on Gozo and the last thing we want more noise pollution and an ugly concrete scar on the face of the island.

The only people who will benefit from an airstrip on Gozo are the developers and the rich set who want to be able to fly their little planes in and out of Gozo whenever they like.

Hands off Gozo. You people have done enough harm to the island. If you want an airlink then bring back the helicopter link.
M. Cachia (on 26/1/09)
While I strongly encourage AOPA's efforts to continue pushing the authorities to make a decision regarding this matter, I must point out that light aircraft, with or without the airstrip will still remain "humming" over Gozo. Private pilot training is usually performed in the Gozo area since this is the location where commercial traffic is less likely to interfere with the training aircraft. I must also point out that these aircraft are very silent aircraft and I do not see any reason why the airstrip and hence the aircraft making use of it, would pose any threats to the tourism sector.
Rod Abela (on 26/1/09)
As secretary Aero Club Malta, I have to clarify that our club had submitted proposals to initially extend the existing 'runway' of 172m to 350m on the western side of the existing heliport. This would allow sport light aircraft to operate and to test whether the environmental concerns (noise, etc) are justified or not. On a personal basis I had supported on various occasions promoters like Franco J. Scicluna and Victor Mercieca long before Mr Perry submitted his proposals. I have a strange feeling that the anti-airstrip lobby is formed by expats living on Gozo... In any case the point is that unless Gozo is given a small 800mt runway strip it will continue to lose on the lucrative revenues generated by light aviation industry and will continue to remain isolated. This is in stark contrast with what is happening in nearby Sicily with the town of Ragusa redeveloping the former NATO airbase at Comiso and Agrigento planning to have its own airstrip. Sleep on Gozo, sleep on!
I Gatt (on 26/1/09)
Gozo may enjoy peace and tranquility and this will certainly not be jeopardised by aircraft flying in and out. It is not an international airport that we seek and aircraft movements would indeed be limited. Gozo and its nationals suffer from double insularity and with todays' dependency on logistics makes this simply unacceptable. The potential for a landing strip in Gozo is indeed high. As an organisation AOPA (Malta) has been a strong advocate in favour of such a strip. It would increase accessibility, attract a different breed of tourists, increase safety and provide rapid transit in the event of an emergency.
As can be imagined an environmental Impact assessment would indeed be carried out, however, according to feasibility studies carried out by AOPA, the impact would be minimal as we had designed the strip to replace the existing dirt road just South of the existing Heli-pad. Our presentation was well received by th GTA and representatives from Gozo's business community and we hope to have the opportunity to present this to the honorable minister for Gozo in due course. AOPA (Malta) also supports initiatives being taken by Messrs. V. Mercieca and R. Perry.
Ivan X. Gatt
President (AOPA) Malta
Peter Green (on 26/1/09)
Tourists and Maltese that come to Gozo for a holiday want total piece and quiteness. Having planes humming above the Gozo tranquil countryside is NOT good for Gozo tourism!

I honestly believe that Gozo Tourism Association lost the plot. One wonders why Gozo Ministry supports GTA with resources when GTA has lost its touch with true tourism in Gozo.
Kurt Shields (on 26/1/09)
I totally agree with Mr. Dempster. Gozo shouldn't be developed any more. We shouldn't make an airstrip.

If the road linking Ghajnsielem to Xewkija can be temporarily closed for operating aircraft, I think that will be a good solution.

However any form of development on countryside is certainly terrible and certainly isn't the right way to help tourism.
M. Cachia (on 26/1/09)
A few metres of runway strip are, in my opinion, negligible to what this airstrip might offer in the long-term. The general aviation sector in Malta has been very active in the last few years, and is becoming increasingly popular among Maltese people. The Gozo airstrip will be a means for local pilots to travel to Gozo with their private planes (hired or their own), and will also attract general aviation pilots from nearby countries. Moreover, there are companies locally which are equipped with light aircraft already and would be probably available for this business. Why use a foreign company when there are already a number of companies locally which might be interested in conducting the flights between the islands? What is the fuss all about? Environment? For a few metres of asphalt?
H Dempster (on 26/1/09)
HANDS OFF BEAUTIFUL GOZO. Dont destory it and leave it as it is , in its natural beauty.

To attract tourists one does not have to build runways. there are many islads , worldwide which are reached by ferries.

So just leave it alone, Look at Malta, it hase become a contrete jungle.

Tuesday, July 29, 2008

The businessmen are marching in...ouch ouch

The Times of Malta decided to give a short account of the presentation of his idea of an airstrip for Gozo The Times reported thus: "A blind Gozitan resident made a presentation on the long-running idea of building an airstrip allowing small passenger aircraft to land in Gozo."

Roy S. Perry, a blind ex-pat residing in Qala, expressed frustration saying that "Gozitan organisations have not exerted enough pressure on the government to improve tourist numbers on the island."

Frank Salt, obviously a supporter of the idea, noted that "It takes a blind man to put forward sensible ideas that will halt the decline in commerce and tourism."

The meeting was concluded with a resolve to form a working party of businessmen who will be approaching the government.

Ouch ouch....the businessmen are coming in.... Once again, several Times readers added their comments on the Times on-line, including those by Roy Perry himself and his wife Josie Perry. Then we have people like the Irish James A. Tyrrell - a regular contributor for the gozonews.com




The comments follow here:

L Galea
There is no need to continue destroying Gozo and increase the noise pollution from aircraft.

As I have already suggested what is needed is a bridge to solve the Shipyard problems, the installation of wind generators on the bridge itself to allievate the energy problem, and the provision of a continuous means of transport between Malta and Gozo solving the problem for Maltese and Gozitans and tourists, especially in an emergency.

Why do businessmen see nothing except their own narrow private interests instead of the common interest of the Maltese and Gozitan people?

Why are they so intent on continuing to destroy more land in both Malta and Gozo?

Leslie Mirasole
There is no need to spoil a large piece of land just for some silly little planes. when Gozo is served better by sea.

E Camilleri
Finally we have a fixed wing sea plane between malta-gozo, why the insistence to continue destroying the last few open spaces? Having an airstrip to increase gozo tourism is false. Leave Gozo in its remaining natural state and then only you can boost tourism or at least keep the numbers.

Maria Dolores Fenech
So Gozo would have a heliport which is no longer functional due to high fees, but an airstrip to accomodate a few businessmen! Would the Gozitans allow this to happen in their (still) unspoilt beautiful island?

James A. Tyrrell
Just what Gozo needs, a big concrete scar covering part of the island. Frank Salt talks about the decline in commerce and tourism. What decline? Everything I've read from the MTA has failed to mention any decline. Stop trying to fool the public with these lies. If anything is going to have a long-term effect on tourism it is the continued destruction of the island by so-called Gozitans and Maltese who care more about making a buck than caring for the environment. Having said that I have no doubt that the party of businessmen will be well received by the Government, as the present Government are nothing short of environmental rapists. As we have already seen just apply enough pressure and perhaps take along a big enough envelope and you will get your wish. Once the tourist trade dries up you can use the airstrip as foundations for high-rise apartments and fill them with illegal immigrants who will be the only people interested in going to Gozo!

Josie Perry
My Husband has spent many years studying the various ideas to improve communications between Malta and Gozo. A bridge will do more to harm the environment during the construction phase than any other civil engineering project. It would have to be in two sections via Comino and would totally destroy the environment in that island. In addoition to that there is the landfall site at Qala with new roads having to be built at both ends. At the pace of construction here it will be 50 years before this is complete. All we ask for is a small airfield to accommodate small aircraft with a link to Sicily for businessmen as well as richer tourist who find it stressful to trqavel by road. Why should Malta have the benefits of these visitors and not Gozo?

James A. Tyrrell
What Gozo needs Josie is what Gozo had before and lost due to lack of Government support, a helicopter service. This could easily accommodate the businessmen between Malta, Gozo and Sicily as well as catering for the tourists willing to pay that bit extra for the privilege of getting to Gozo quicker. Another problem you didn't raise with regard to the bridge idea would be the increase of crime on Gozo due to the direct road access.

L Galea
No Josie A bridge will not do any more harm. It will provide work for the shipyard workers during construction and maintenance, provide occasion to build a windfarm on the same bridge to reduce Malta's dependence on fossil fuels and thus better the environment and the exchequer's balance, and provide an uninterruptible road service to the Maltese and Gozitan people including TOURISTS who will enjoy a breathtaking view of the channel, and which will be extremely useful when incliment weather prevents any other means of transport from operating, including smal aircraft and helicopters. And why may I ask will a bridge ruin Comino's environment? By allowing easier access to Maltese, Gozitans and tourists? Or do you want it to be reserved for certain types of persons whoever and whatever they be who like isolation from other people's eyes? Would you perhaps recommend such a project in your home country which you have left Mrs Perry?

Victor G. Mercieca
These very negative people who oppose rapid air commuting most likely have a good eye sight but prefer not to see! Airplanes are not silly, they are man's best invention which greatly enhances anybody's life in more ways then one, it seems these people have no idea & are installing a false picture! Maybe they prefer the site in question to continue be used as a dump site & a derelict heliport! Aircraft Owners & Pilots Association USA A valued member since 1993 # 01161606

James A. Tyrrell
Victor the comments in question are not negative, at least from the point of view of caring about the island of Gozo and its environment. Gozo is approximately 9 miles by 4 miles and you think it would be a good idea to cover yet more of it in concrete. I don't think so. To build an airstrip here would not only create an ugly concrete scar on the island; it would also destroy ancient cart ruts and rare plants. But that's okay so long as the few can benefit. I can guarantee you that if this ever happens in no time at all some idiot will be calling for it to be extended so that international flights can land, and if the right palms are greased I've no doubt that would happen too. The area in question by the way was being used as a dumpsite long before the helicopter service pulled out. Gozo does not and never will need an airstrip in the same way that it does not need a marina at Hondoq. The time has long since passed when people need to wake up and give this island treasure what it really needs, protection

Eugenio Taliana
During bad weather the seaplane does not operate, the Gozo ferry does not operate and even sometimes the Helicopter did not operate - what you, in Gozo need, is something that bad weather does not hinder its operations! is there a solution?

Roy Perry
I would prefer comments to be constructive and not personal. I have lived in Gozo since 1990 and have no home elsewhere. I have always tried to improve the standard of life and information in my adopted country and have generally been treated with respect.
Gozo will not benefit from a bridge which will cost hundreds of millions of Euros. The airlink proposals CANNOT be extended to include larger aircraft.
A. Because there is no need.
B. Because the Tarmac (not concrete) strip will not bear their weight.

So far as damage to the heritage and archaeology in concerned, I know exactly where every Cart Rut, Temple fragment, Bore Hole, Sewerage Outfall, etc. is located on the site. An airfield is a protected area where flora can thrive. If the development also looks after these heritage issues it is surely better than letting them be un-recognised or fall into decay - like the 16th Century St. Cecilia Chapel which is falling down for want of attention.

I have nothing to gain financially from the project - now isn't that foolish!

Raymond Sammut
An airstrip in Gozo would create an indelible mark on the tiny picturesque sister island. If presently there is some kind of a dump there, then the dump should be cleared, and the area tidied up. We are not to fix a wrong with something which is clearly incongruous. Now imagine living on a tiny island with small propeller aircrafts hovering over your roof. They are always looking for this damnable airstrip so they can land. It would make me feel nervous. These things are notorious for falling off the sky. All it takes is some pilot error, or something going loose in the mechanics. Once it happens, it happens. An entire family is gone. Now, that so much has been "invested", the airstrip will not go away. There will be an investigation to find out what caused the tragedy, but the show must go on -- Gozitans will simply have to get used to it. You're kidding me. I also have to disagree with you, L Galea. There are now 250,000 cars registered. Once you build a bridge, these cars will incessantly be heading Gozo's way. Gozo too will be infected with pollution as Malta is now.

Barry Drake
Having been involved in the traveling side of things since1986 and now residing for the past eight years there is something that puzzles me. Why, after building an acceptable sized heliport that coped quite well, is there never any talk about having a helicopter service again rather than a fixed wing service? Everyone says it not financially viable, but I`m sure that there must be some one with the same business acumen as Sir Richard Branson and who could see the benefits that such a service would bring to the island. I for one think it has been the best system used during my many visits since 1986

ouch when the saints
ouch when the saints
ouch when the saints go marching in...

Mind you, the word 'saints' in the local context has a very political meaning.
It's like when one says that "a saint in need is a saint indeed".

Ouch ouch

Is an air link a real necessity?

People like Franco J. Scicluna would say yes.

One of the reasons (?) Mr. Scicluna gives is that "If only a serious air service was in operation between Gozo and Malta International Airport a lot of hassle and hardship would have been avoided during the (bus) strike."
In his letter to The Times on Friday 25th July 2008 he wrote about a serious inter-island air service.

Once again, his letter provoked other people to add their comments on The Times on-line.

Here they are:

apgrech
What's wrong with extending Gozo's runway a bit and put two or three smaller aircrafts to service between Malta and Gozo? If prices are reasonable, the service will be used by many.


John Portelli
Gozo needs a viable airlink. Period. It's ridiculous that in this day and age, there is no airlink. We have gone back so much in time, it's not even funny. Is this what we call progress. Or is this a big joke.

Liam Kelly
So we're trying to justify using air transport to take us the gigantic distance of a few miles?

The spannish company stopped operating for a reason; no market.

Isn't it obvious what Roy Perry will want given is well known agenda?

The truth is it is unrealistic, unnecessary, irresponsible and down right damaging to have any form of air link to Gozo, deep down we all know that.

Hovercraft is the answer.

N Palmer
@Liam Kelly

I think you will find that Helisureste stopped operations because the cost associated with operating a helicopter in terms of maintenance and fuel far outweighed the price that people were willing to pay for the ticket.

It's not that there is no market for an air-link to Gozo but rather than it needs to be a cost effective solution, and helicopters are not the answer! This means that an air-link can only be served by a suitable fixed wing aircraft, and then one goes back to the various ongoing issues that have been discussed over the past couple of years.

Vincent Gauci
Before jumping to hasty conclusions about the need for increasing the length of the air strip in Gozo, we should see how this would feature within the concept of Gozo as an eco-island.

John Mizzi
If the heliport is not going to be used it should be decommissioned and all the buried cart ruts underneath uncovered. The Roman vine canals should be cleared as well and the whole area turned into a tourism archaeological park. The heritage superintendence should schedule the whole area ASAP. At Ta' Lambert Gozitans go to worship the Virgin Mary since they realize that the whole area is a special place.

L Galea
A Gozo aircraft link with the necessary extension to the runway is simply a continuation of the rape of Gozo. A bridge is an all-weather means of linking the Islands.

I agree with John Mizzi that the Roman vine canals be uncovered as they would serve as a tourist attraction.

How on earth can you boast of an eco-island when you want to continue to rape it to satisfy your greed and comfort?

Liam Kelly
@ N Palmer

So your saying when Helsureste did their feasibility research in the first place they thought...there's a market....so it must work....Operating costs... what are those?

Perhaps not.


Roy S. Perry
I wish to thank Franco for keeping the subject in view. The problem here is that nobody listens to exactly what is being proposed nor do they appreciate the need. There is a perfectly good ferry service for commuters in both directions. There is NOT a quick, comfortable and reliable fast link for our visitors, the elderly or infirm, those without patience or medical staff.

Go to the GozoAirlink blog and note that 85% of voters support it. Ask most Gozitans and they agree. Most of all, why don't we stop this 'pussyfooting about' and set up a meeting to exchange ideas instead of this perpetual slanging match.

An Airlink will bring discerning visitors, a bridge would ONLY be valid between communities of similar size. Most of all, I say, let Gozo decide.

By the way, I have designed and costed the idea of a bridge (actually two would be needed - via Comino - and a submersible tunnel. Both options are incredibly expensive and impractical. This, after all, is not Manhatten!

James A. Tyrrell
First of all I would like to say that I support what John Mizzi says 100%. I also agree with most of what Liam Kelly says although I don't think a hovercraft is the answer. Nor is a bridge as suggested by L Galea. The problem with a bridge apart from the obvious one of cost is that it provides easy access for criminals.

As for Roy S. Perry and his desire to concrete over more of the little island of Gozo I would be interested in knowing if he personally has a vested interest in any such development.

The only answer and the least disruptive one given the short distance involved and the small size of the island is a restoration of the helicopter service. If the Government were serious about Gozo as an Eco island then surely they would be more than willing to subsidise such a service to protect the Gozo environment.

Adrian Cardona
"The problem with a bridge apart from the obvious one of cost is that it provides easy access for criminals"
What kind of reason is that??!! Are you worried that poor crime-free Gozo will be raped and pillaged by the nefarious Maltese?

apgrech
I had a second thought. To go to Gozo by ferry say from Lija, one would have to drive to Cirkewwa. If same person have to fly to Gozo, s/he has to drive to Luqa so, it's Cikku briku plus, one can't go by car if s/he uses the aircraft.

It is amazing what reasons people who say they arte in favour of an airstrip on this little island comes up with. As if the buses strike which occured in malta mid this month are going to take place on a monthly basis! As if the sea between Malta and Gozo is going to be so rough that the 20-minute ferry will stop working!

On the otherhand it seems that for a 20 minute ferry journey, some are ready to put more tarmac and cement the whole idea once and for all.